The English version has not yet been audited. Please use it for reference only.

Studies in Buddhist Thought

History of philosophy · critique of soteriology · history of transformation

Studies in Buddhist Thought is a three-volume series. Volume I traces the history of Buddhist philosophy from its ancient Indian background to the modern period. Volume II critically examines the soteriologies of Madhyamaka, Yogācāra, tathāgatagarbha, Vajrayāna, and Pure Land. Volume III asks what forces drove each major transformation in Buddhist history.

A History of Buddhist Philosophy cover
Volume 1

A History of Buddhist Philosophy

A systematic history of Buddhist philosophy, from its ancient Indian background to contemporary developments.

Start reading →
Front MatterPreface
Part 1: Background and OriginsChapter 1: India Before the Buddha—The Vedas, Brahmanism, and Social Structure
Chapter 2: The Upaniṣads and the Core Problems—Karma, Rebirth, and Liberation
Chapter 3: The Renunciant Movement—Jainism, Fatalism, Materialism, and Skepticism
Chapter 4: The Historical Buddha—Reconstructing a Life without the Myths
Chapter 5: The Earliest Teachings—The Four Truths, Dependent Origination, Non-Self, and the Five Aggregates
Part 2: Early Sangha and School DivisionsChapter 1: Formation of the Sangha and the Vinaya
Chapter 2: Councils and the Oral Transmission of Scripture
Chapter 3 The Root Schism: The Sthaviras and the Mahāsāṃghikas
Chapter 4 The Proliferation of the Schools: Eighteen or Twenty?
Chapter 5 The Rise of Abhidharma
Part 3: Philosophy of the Early SchoolsChapter 1 Sarvāstivāda: The Three Times Really Exist, and the Intrinsic Nature of Dharmas Always Exists
Chapter 2 The *Mahāvibhāṣā* and the Sarvāstivāda System
Chapter 3 Sautrāntika: Seeds, Momentary Cessation, and Continuity
Chapter 4 Theravāda Abhidhamma
Chapter 5 The Vātsīputrīyas and the Problem of the Person
Chapter 6 Core Controversies: Time, Causality, Mind, and Mental Factors
Part 4: Rise of MahayanaChapter 1 The Problem of Mahāyāna Origins: Evidence and Hypotheses
Chapter 2 Early Mahāyāna Scriptures: Prajñāpāramitā, Lotus, Avataṃsaka, Pure Land, and Vimalakīrti
Chapter 3 The Bodhisattva Path and a New Ideal of Practice
Chapter 4 Mahāyāna and the Early Schools
Part 5: MadhyamakaChapter 1 Nāgārjuna: The *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā*, Emptiness, Dependent Arising, and the Two Truths
Chapter 2 Āryadeva and Early Madhyamaka
Chapter 3 Madhyamaka Methods of Argument
Chapter 4 Buddhapālita and Bhāviveka: The Division between Svātantrika and Prāsaṅgika
Chapter 5 Candrakīrti and Prāsaṅgika Madhyamaka
Chapter 6 Argumentative Slippages in Prajñāpāramitā and Madhyamaka Texts
Part 6: YogacaraChapter 1 The Maitreya Treatises and the Formation of Yogācāra
Chapter Two: Asaṅga—The *Mahāyānasaṃgraha* and Storehouse Consciousness
Chapter Three: Vasubandhu—The *Twenty Verses* and *Thirty Verses on Consciousness-Only*
Chapter Four: The Three Natures, Three Absences of Nature, and Transformation of the Basis
Chapter Five: The Debate between Consciousness-Only and Madhyamaka
Part 7: Tathagatagarbha and Buddha NatureChapter One: The Tathāgatagarbha Sūtras
Chapter Two: The *Ratnagotravibhāga*
Chapter Three: Tathāgatagarbha, Consciousness-Only, and Madhyamaka
Chapter Four: The Later Influence of Tathāgatagarbha in China and Tibet
Part 8: Late Indian BuddhismChapter One: Dignāga—Foundations of Buddhist Logic and Epistemology
Chapter Two: Dharmakīrti’s Logic and Epistemology
Chapter Three: Śāntarakṣita and Kamalaśīla—Synthesizing Madhyamaka and Yogācāra
Chapter Four: The Rise of Esoteric Buddhism and Vajrayāna
Chapter Five: Nālandā, Vikramaśīla, and the Late Great Monasteries
Chapter Six: The Decline of Buddhism in India—An Inference from Historical Sources
Part 9: Southern BuddhismChapter One: Transmission to Sri Lanka and the Conflict between Mahāvihāra and Abhayagiri
Chapter Two: Buddhaghosa, the *Visuddhimagga*, and the Commentarial Tradition
Chapter Three: Southeast Asia—Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia, and Laos
Chapter 4: Doctrine and Meditation Traditions
Chapter 5: Modern Reform and Development
Part 10: Chinese BuddhismChapter 1: Transmission and Early Sūtra Translation—An Shigao, Lokakṣema, and Dao’an
Chapter 2: Matching Concepts and Early Interpretation
Chapter 3: Kumārajīva, the Three Treatises, and Sengzhao
Chapter 4: The History of Sūtra Translation and Xuanzang
Chapter 5: The Tiantai School
Chapter 6: The Huayan School
Chapter 7: The Consciousness-Only or Faxiang School
Chapter 8: The Chan School
Chapter 9: The Pure Land School
Chapter 10: The Vinaya, Esoteric, and Other Schools
Chapter 11: Modern Chinese Buddhism and Humanistic Buddhism
Part 11: Tibetan BuddhismChapter 1: The Early Diffusion—Imperial Tibet and the Samye Debate
Chapter 2: The Beginning of the Later Diffusion
Chapter 3: Nyingma and Dzogchen
Chapter 4: Kagyu and Mahāmudrā
Chapter 5: The Sakya School
Chapter 6: Gelug and Tsongkhapa
Chapter 7: The Madhyamaka Debate—Self-Emptiness and Other-Emptiness
Chapter 8: Tibetan Buddhism in the Modern and Contemporary Periods
Part 12: Modern and Contemporary TrendsChapter 1: Buddhist Modernism
Chapter 2: The Transmission of Buddhism to the West
Chapter 3: Methods and Advances in Academic Buddhist Studies
Chapter 4: New Developments from 1990 to 2020
Chapter 5: Buddhism During and After the Pandemic
Chapter 6: Buddhism and Feminism
Part II: Philosophical AnalysisReader's Guide: Expansion, Necessary Repetition, and Deeper Analysis
Part II: Philosophical Analysis · Part 13: Analysis of Early TeachingsChapter 1, Part II: Map of the Metaphysical Frontier
Chapter 1, Part I: The Fourteen Undeclared Questions and the Outline of Early Buddhist Metaphysics
Chapter 2: Nibbāna, the Similes of Fire and Tree, and a Phenomenological Approach
Chapter 3: The Five Aggregates, the Four Great Elements, and Not-Self
Chapter 4: Dependent Arising and Psychodynamic Analysis
Chapter 5: Rebirth, the Destinations, and the Three Realms
Chapter 6: Bodhisattva, Buddha, and the Four Fruits
Chapter 7: Leaves in the Hand—Metaphysical Restraint and Inevitable Leakage
Chapter 8: The Author's Reflections—The Allure of Metaphysics
Part II: Philosophical Analysis · Part 14: Analysis of Theravada AbhidhammaChapter 0: Guide to This Part
Chapter 1: Mind, Matter, and Continuity—The Questions Abhidhamma Taxonomy Seeks to Answer
Chapter 2: Nāma—A Taxonomy of Mental Phenomena
Chapter 3: Rūpa—A Taxonomy of Material Phenomena
Chapter 4: Citta-vīthi: A Taxonomy of Mental Processes
Chapter 5: The Twenty-Four Conditions: A Taxonomy of Relations
Chapter 6: Continuity: Time, Rebirth, and the End of Continuity
Chapter 7: Restraint and the Vacancies
Part II: Philosophical Analysis · Part 15: Analysis of Sarvastivada PhilosophyChapter 0: Guide to This Part
Chapter 1: Sarvāstitva—Substance and Function, Real and Nominal
Chapter 2: The Seventy-Five Dharmas—Another List
Chapter 3: Existence in the Three Times—The Dharma Substance in Time
Chapter 4: Persistence—Possession, Unmanifest Matter, and Formal Entities
Chapter 5: Six Causes and Four Conditions—Another Algorithm for Relations
Chapter 6: Atoms and Aggregation—The Material End
Chapter 7: Entities and Regress
AppendicesTerminology Concordance (for All Volumes)
Afterword
A Critique of Buddhist Soteriology cover
Volume 2

A Critique of Buddhist Soteriology

A critical examination of the soteriological claims of Madhyamaka, Yogācāra, tathāgatagarbha, Vajrayāna, and Pure Land.

Start reading →
Front MatterPreface
Part 1: IntroductionChapter 1: The Problem Structure of Soteriology
Chapter 2: The Early Buddhist Soteriological Baseline
Chapter 3: The Southern Route—Abhidhamma Soteriology and Its Cost
Chapter 4: An Overview of the Transformation of Mahāyāna Soteriology
Part 2: Madhyamaka Soteriology · Part I: Soteriological OverviewPart I, Chapter 1: Emptiness and Liberation—The Core Claim
Part I, Chapter 2: Early Madhyamaka’s Theory of Practice—Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva
Part I, Chapter 3: Candrakīrti and the Prāsaṅgika Path of Liberation
Part 2: Madhyamaka Soteriology · Part II: Critique of SoteriologyPart II, Chapter 1: The Truth of Suffering—Is Suffering in Formations or in View?
Part II, Chapter 2: The Truth of Origin—Which Level Does Madhyamaka’s Diagnosis Strike?
Part II, Chapter 3: The Truth of Cessation—Deobjectification and Reobjectification
Part II, Chapter 4: The Truth of the Path I—From Indirect Cultivation Back to Direct Confrontation
Part II, Chapter 5: The Truth of the Path II—The Tension Between Having No Thesis and Practice
Part II, Chapter 6: Verification—The Drift in Certifying Realization
Part II, Chapter 7: Judgment of Attachment—Functional Clinging and Ultimate Truth
Part II, Chapter 8: Overall Assessment—Claim and Function
Part 3: Yogacara Soteriology · Part I: Soteriological OverviewPart I, Chapter 1: Consciousness-Only and Liberation—The Core Claim
Part I, Chapter 2: The Yogins’ Theory of Practice—The *Śrāvakabhūmi* and the Five Stages
Part I, Chapter 3: Systematization—Seed Theory and the *Cheng Weishi Lun*
Part 3: Yogacara Soteriology · Part II: Critique of SoteriologyPart II, Chapter 1: The Truth of Suffering—From Observable Formations to an Unknowable Storehouse
Part II, Chapter 2: The Truth of Origin—The Discovery of Manas and the Abyss of Iteration
Part II, Chapter 3: The Truth of Cessation—Transformation of the Basis: Cessation or Upgrade?
Part II, Chapter 4: The Truth of the Path I—Consciousness-Only Contemplation and the Continuation of Confrontation
Part II, Chapter 5: The Truth of the Path II—Seed Theory and the Mechanism’s Idle Rotation
Part II, Chapter 6: Verification—Unknowable Appropriation and the Five-Stage Checkpoints
Part II, Chapter 7: Determining Attachment—Attachment to a Foundation
Part II, Chapter 8: Concluding Audit—Claims and Functions
Part 4: Tathagatagarbha Soteriology · Part I: Soteriological OverviewPart I, Chapter 1: Buddha-Nature and Liberation—The Core Claim
Part I, Chapter 2: The Theory of Practice—Entry Through Faith and the Removal of Obstructions
Part 4: Tathagatagarbha Soteriology · Part II: Critique of SoteriologyPart II, Chapter 1: The Truths of Suffering and Origin—Suffering Becomes a Guest
Part II, Chapter 2: The Truth of Cessation—The Door Pushed Open
Part II, Chapter 3: The Truth of the Path—The Paradox of Polishing the Mirror
Part II, Chapter 4: Verification—A Path with Nothing to Verify
Part II, Chapter 5: Determining Attachment and Concluding Audit—Attachment to Eternity
Part 5: Vajrayana Soteriology · Part I: Soteriological OverviewPart I, Chapter 1: Buddhahood in This Very Body—The Core Claim
Part I, Chapter 2: The Theory of Practice—Empowerment, Deity, and Subtle Body
Part 5: Vajrayana Soteriology · Part II: Critique of SoteriologyPart II, Chapter 1: The Truths of Suffering and Origin—The Physiology of Affliction
Part II, Chapter 2: The Truths of Cessation and Path—Taking the Fruit as the Path
Part II, Chapter 3: Verification—Signs of Attainment and Teacherly Authority
Part II, Chapter 4: Determining Attachment and Concluding Audit—Attachment to the Result
Part 6: Pure Land Soteriology · Part I: Soteriological OverviewPart I, Chapter 1: From Liberation to Salvation—The Core Claim
Part I, Chapter 2: Internal Defenses—Two Paths, Two Gates, and the Final Dharma
Part 6: Pure Land Soteriology · Part II: Critique of SoteriologyPart II, Chapter 1: The Truths of Suffering and Origin—From Abandoning Affliction to Seeking Rescue
Part II, Chapter 2: The Truths of Cessation and Path—The Guarantee of Other-Power
Part II, Chapter 3: Verification—A Check from Which No One Returns
Part II, Chapter 4: Determining Attachment and Concluding Audit—Attachment to Salvation
Part 7: Synthetic CriticismChapter 1: A Comparative Analysis of the Five Soteriologies
Chapter 2: Shared Tendencies in Mahāyāna Soteriology
Chapter 3: What Makes a Soteriology Credible?
Chapter 4: Conclusion—Returning to the Original Concern
Part 8: AppendicesAppendix I: Comparison with Yinshun’s Doctrinal Classification—Two Roads Back to the Original Concern
Appendix II: Modern Forms of Madhyamaka—Re-Testing the Verdict
A History of Buddhist Transformation cover
Volume 3

A History of Buddhist Transformation

A history of the political, institutional, economic, and intellectual forces behind Buddhism's major transformations.

Start reading →
Front MatterPreface
Part 1: IntroductionChapter 1: Why Buddhism Kept Changing
Chapter 2: Six Lines of External Causation
Chapter 3: The Discipline of Arguments About Hidden Motives
Part 2: Fragmentation After the Buddhas DeathChapter 1: The Vacuum of Authority—The Buddha Appoints No Successor
Chapter 2: The Politics of the Councils—Whose Memory Counts?
Chapter 3: The Root Schism—The Ten Points, Mahādeva, and Two Buddhist Imaginaries
Interlude: Innumerable Saints—An Impossible Census
Part 3: ScholasticizationChapter 1: From Practice Ground to Academy—The Abhidharma Movement
Chapter 2: The First Encounter with Kingship—The Aśokan Model
Chapter 3: Freezing on an Island—The Formation of Theravāda
Part 4: The Rise of MahayanaChapter 1: The Mechanism of New Sūtras—A Media Revolution
Chapter 2: Replacing the Ideal—The Bodhisattva Beyond Inspection
Chapter 3: From Teacher to Savior—The Elevation of the Buddha
Chapter 4: Who Pushed? Three Populations, Three Mahāyāna Movements
Part 5: The Debate ArenaChapter 1: The Arms Race—Why Buddhism Needed Philosophy
Chapter 2: The Nālandā System—The Ecology of Scholar-Monks
Chapter 3: The Cost of Debate—The Drift in Criteria
Part 6: The Return of the True and EternalChapter 1: The Gravity of Brahmanization—The Gupta-Age Market
Chapter 2: The Business of Annihilation Fear—The Demand Side of the True and Eternal
Part 7: TantricizationChapter 1: The Ritual Takeover—From Protective Charms to Deity Yoga
Chapter 2: Borrowed Technology—The Problem of Shared Origins with Śaivism
Chapter 3: Incorporating the Anti-Establishment—Siddhas and Universities
Part 8: The Death of Indian BuddhismChapter 1: A Slow Death—The Loss of the Lay Base
Chapter 2: All Eggs in One Basket—The Fragility of the Monastic Economy
Chapter 3: The Death Report—Weighing Three Causes
Part 9: Entry into China and TranslationChapter 1: Borrowing a Shell—Matching Concepts and the Vogue for *Xuanxue*
Chapter 2: The Translation Bureau—The Politics of the Translation Movement
Chapter 3: The Market of Disorder—Why Buddhism Prevailed in an Age of Division
Part 10: Chinese ReconstructionChapter 1: Doctrinal Classification—The Operation That Incorporated the Entire Inheritance
Chapter 2: Chinese Systems—Tiantai and Huayan
Chapter 3: The Formation of Chan—Rebellion against Scholasticism
Chapter 4: The Formation of Pure Land—Buddhism for the People
Part 11: The Surviving Forms of Chinese BuddhismChapter 1: The Economics of Huichang—Suppression and Selection
Chapter 2: Printing and the Literati—Chinese Buddhism's Position after Song
Chapter 3: The Convergence of Chan and Pure Land—The Survivors' Form
Part 12: The Tibetan SynthesisChapter 1: Two Imports and Samye—The Route by Royal Decree
Chapter 2: The Politics of the Tulku—Reincarnation as Institution
Chapter 3: Gelug's Victory—Union of Religion and Politics
Part 13: Japans Simplifying RevolutionChapter 1: Kamakura New Buddhism—The Revolution of the Single Practice
Chapter 2: Tokugawa Household Registration—The *Terauke* System
Chapter 3: The Meiji Shock—After the Destruction of Buddhism
Part 14: Modernitys RewritingChapter 1: Buddhist Modernism—Rewritten for the Examiner
Chapter 2: Humanistic Buddhism—Chinese Buddhism's Self-Rescue
Chapter 3: The Mindfulness Industry—The Final Incorporation
Part 15: The Shape of TransformationChapter 1: Does Transformation Have a Direction?—The Engine of the Whole Volume
Conclusion: A Candid Account of the Hidden Tools

The three main volumes are complete. Essays and further translations will follow.